By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
IndebtaIndebta
  • Home
  • News
  • Banking
  • Credit Cards
  • Loans
  • Mortgage
  • Investing
  • Markets
    • Stocks
    • Commodities
    • Crypto
    • Forex
  • Videos
  • More
    • Finance
    • Dept Management
    • Small Business
Notification Show More
Aa
IndebtaIndebta
Aa
  • Banking
  • Credit Cards
  • Loans
  • Dept Management
  • Mortgage
  • Markets
  • Investing
  • Small Business
  • Videos
  • Home
  • News
  • Banking
  • Credit Cards
  • Loans
  • Mortgage
  • Investing
  • Markets
    • Stocks
    • Commodities
    • Crypto
    • Forex
  • Videos
  • More
    • Finance
    • Dept Management
    • Small Business
Follow US
Indebta > News > The west shouldn’t give up on ‘gentle commerce’ just yet
News

The west shouldn’t give up on ‘gentle commerce’ just yet

News Room
Last updated: 2023/08/08 at 4:40 PM
By News Room
Share
7 Min Read
SHARE

Receive free Global trade updates

We’ll send you a myFT Daily Digest email rounding up the latest Global trade news every morning.

One of the oldest and most persistent ideas of the western enlightenment is the civilising force of free economic exchange. The belief that trade and political concord reinforce one another — at times called doux commerce or “gentle commerce” — goes back at least as far as Montesquieu’s writings 300 years ago.

This belief motivated some of the weightiest economic decisions of the past 50 years: Washington’s welcome of China into the World Trade Organization; Germany’s determination to tie itself to Russia in a relationship of energy-based interdependence; and the EU’s confidence that its granting of membership could turn poor, unstable neighbours at risk of authoritarianism into bulwarks of liberal democracy.

In each case, an overarching confidence in the link between economic growth and political liberalism joined more selfish motives to tip the scales in favour of deeper economic ties.

Granting China permanent market access while tying it into the global architecture of trading rules would, many thought, strengthen its reformers. Germany’s pipeline policy paired industrialists’ interest in cheap gas with the nobler justification of Wandel durch Handel, or “change through trade”: that Russia’s elites would conclude from economic rewards of ties with the west that they should emulate its example. The EU accession process demonstrated its power to drive liberalising reforms many times over since the 1980s.

But in the past 20 years, the modern incarnation of the doux commerce thesis has taken some significant knocks. Far from “westernising” poorer, less democratic countries, today’s consensus is that economic integration undermined liberal democracy in the west while giving autocracies the added appeal of economic strength.

The charge sheet looks damning enough. The “China shock” is blamed for hollowing out manufacturing and creating demoralised “left-behind” regions in the US and beyond. Since Xi Jinping rose to the top in Beijing, he has increased repression inside China and aggression outside, burying hopes for political liberalisation or support for the rules-based global order.

Moscow’s brutal assault on Ukraine has put paid to Wandel durch Handel — and should have done so when Putin’s Russia first attempted to dismember Ukraine in 2014. The spell of EU integration has been broken, with not just prospective but current members, from Turkey to Hungary, turning their backs on pluralist liberalism. And through it all, the global financial crisis and its political aftermath undermined western countries’ credibility as examples of the notion that prosperity and liberal democratic governance go hand in hand.

But look closer and the story these events tell is more complex, and more flattering for the old view of liberalism and prosperity’s codependence.

Start with China. Expectations of a strong rebound once Beijing abandoned its repressive version of “zero Covid” have given way to economic pessimism. Waning growth prospects look increasingly like a consequence of Xi’s shift from a developmental to a security state.

As Adam Posen highlights in an important new essay, the extreme arbitrariness of Beijing’s Covid policy “reinforced the sense among Chinese people that their jobs, businesses, and everyday routines remain at the mercy of the party”. Arbitrary political interventions kill the willingness to spend and invest in illiquid assets, as “risk aversion and greater precautionary savings act as a drag on growth, rather like what happens in the aftermath of a financial crisis”.

Rather than disproving the old liberal belief, China increasingly looks like it was at most a temporary exception that confirms the rule.

We also cannot dismiss the EU’s power to drive liberal reforms. In some cases it remains strong, most evidently in Ukraine where it has fuelled economic and governance reforms for a decade. In Hungary and Poland, the very fact of EU membership has restrained their authoritarian slide: just imagine what Viktor Orbán or Jarosław Kaczyński could have wrought had their countries been outside the bloc. As for Turkey, its liberalising era ended when it became clear EU membership was not in fact on offer, due to opposition from members such as France.

Far from refuting claims of a link between liberal economic exchange and political liberalisation, these cases rather show that, over time, liberalism and prosperity decline (or hold up) together.

If anything disproves the thesis, it would seem to be Russia — and other petrostates like Saudi Arabia. But recognise these for the special cases they are: not diverse webs of deepening economic exchange so much as monopolised supplies of essential inputs. The west’s mistake was not to believe in the power of doux commerce, but in seeing these ties as bona fide commerce rather than geostrategic shakedowns.

Consider, too, how liberal democracies substituted for Russian energy in record time. In a vindication for the liberalism-prosperity link, their political system helped address economic emergencies when it mattered most.

Besides, Russia has only begun to be tested by its far-from-complete economic isolation. To achieve the hoped-for political effects, it must be cut off more thoroughly and for longer. The west would do well to rediscover the patience and courage of its convictions.

martin.sandbu@ft.com

Read the full article here

News Room August 8, 2023 August 8, 2023
Share this Article
Facebook Twitter Copy Link Print
Leave a comment Leave a comment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Finance Weekly Newsletter

Join now for the latest news, tips, and analysis about personal finance, credit cards, dept management, and many more from our experts.
Join Now
EU to stockpile critical minerals due to war risk

Unlock the Editor’s Digest for freeRoula Khalaf, Editor of the FT, selects…

Markets can “breathe a sigh of relief” once tariff news gets out. 🗞️

Watch full video on YouTube

CNBC tests the viral Dubai chocolate bars

Watch full video on YouTube

How trade tensions are really affecting the global economy

When the UK became the first country to reach a trade agreement…

Hamas gives ‘positive’ response to Trump proposal for Gaza ceasefire

Unlock the Editor’s Digest for freeRoula Khalaf, Editor of the FT, selects…

- Advertisement -
Ad imageAd image

You Might Also Like

News

EU to stockpile critical minerals due to war risk

By News Room
News

How trade tensions are really affecting the global economy

By News Room
News

Hamas gives ‘positive’ response to Trump proposal for Gaza ceasefire

By News Room
News

Valve conquered PC gaming. What comes next?

By News Room
News

Saudi Arabia sticks with Iran after Israel war

By News Room
News

BCG modelled plan to ‘relocate’ Palestinians from Gaza

By News Room
News

US threatens EU with 17% tariff on food exports

By News Room
News

Donald Trump and Volodymyr Zelenskyy discuss Ukrainian air defence as Russian attacks mount

By News Room
Facebook Twitter Pinterest Youtube Instagram
Company
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Press Release
  • Contact
  • Advertisement
More Info
  • Newsletter
  • Market Data
  • Credit Cards
  • Videos

Sign Up For Free

Subscribe to our newsletter and don't miss out on our programs, webinars and trainings.

I have read and agree to the terms & conditions
Join Community

2023 © Indepta.com. All Rights Reserved.

Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?